| 2023 CHSAA Class AA State Playoff Bracket | |||||
| OUTBRACKET | ROUND 1 | QUARTERFINAL | SEMI FINAL | FINAL | |
| February 24, 2023 | March 1, 2023 | March 5, 2023 | March 8, 2023 | March 12, 2023 | |
| BQ1 Christ The King (22-4) | |||||
| 76-55 | BQ1 Christ The King (23-4) | ||||
| @ Fordham University | |||||
| BQ 5 Bishop Loughlin (5-19) | |||||
| 75-65 | BQ 5 Bishop Loughlin (6-19) | ||||
| @ St. Francis Prep | |||||
| NY 4 St. Raymond (10-15) | |||||
| 49-42 | NY2 Stepinac (20-9) | ||||
| @ St. John's University | |||||
| BQ 3 Molloy (15-11) | |||||
| 64-59 | BQ 3 Molloy (16-11) | ||||
| @ St. Francis Prep | |||||
| NY 6 Scanlan (10-15) | |||||
| 56-52 | NY2 Stepinac (19-9) | ||||
| @ Fordham University | |||||
| NY2 Stepinac (18-9) | |||||
| 69-66 | NY2 Stepinac (21-9) | ||||
| @ St. John's University | State Class AA Champion | ||||
| March 2, 2023 | |||||
| NY1 Cardinal Hayes (17-9) | |||||
| 58-54 | NY1 Cardinal Hayes (18-9) | ||||
| @ Fordham University | |||||
| NY 5 St. Peter's (17-8) | |||||
| 61-58 | NY 5 St. Peter's (18-8) | ||||
| @ St, Raymond | |||||
| BQ 4 Xaverian (15-11) | |||||
| NY1 Cardinal Hayes (19-9) | |||||
| 69-58 | |||||
| @ St. John's University | |||||
| NY3 Iona Prep (16-10) | |||||
| BQ6 Holy Cross (5-19) | 55-51 | NY3 Iona Prep (17-10) | |||
| @ St, Raymond | |||||
| 50-49 | BQ6 Holy Cross (6-19) | ||||
| @ Christ The King | |||||
| NY7 Mt. St. Michael (7-18) | 75-54 | BQ2 St. Francis Prep (19-8) | |||
| @ Fordham University | |||||
| BQ2 St. Francis Prep (18-8) | |||||