| 2023 New York City Athletic League Tournament | |||
| NYSAIS | |||
| QUARTERFINAL | SEMI FINAL | FINAL | |
| February 10, 2023 | February 14, 2023 | February 16, 2023 | |
| 1 Trevor Day (19-3) | |||
| 54-45 | 1 Trevor Day (20-3) | ||
| @ Highest Seed | |||
| 5 Browning (9-13) | |||
| 69-46 | 4 Calhoun (12-8) | ||
| @ Highest Seed | |||
| 4 Calhoun (10-8) | |||
| 66-50 | 1 Trevor Day (21-3) | ||
| @ Spence Athletic Center | NYCAL CHAMPION | ||
| 3 Columbia Prep (11-9) | |||
| 75-54 | 3 Columbia Prep (12-9) | ||
| @ Highest Seed | |||
| 6 Lycee Francais De NY (2-10) | |||
| 76-65 | 3 Columbia Prep (13-9) | ||
| @ Highest Seed | |||
| 7 UNIS (1-14) | |||
| Forfeit | 2 Loyola (13-7) | ||
| @ Highest Seed | |||
| 2 Loyola (12-7) | |||