| 2023 NYSAIS Class C Playoff Bracket | ||||
| QUARTERFINAL | SEMI FINAL | FINAL | ||
| February 24, 2023 | February 26, 2023 | February 28, 2023 | ||
| 1 Trevor Day (22-3) | ||||
| 64-44 | 1 Trevor Day (23-3) | |||
| @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 8 Birch Wathan Lenox (15-2) | ||||
| 59-54 | 5 York Prep (20-2) | |||
| @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 5 York Prep (18-2) | ||||
| 69-62 | 5 York Prep (19-2) | |||
| @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 4 Friends Seminary (13-10) | ||||
| 74-63 | 3 Trinity (12-10) | |||
| @ Spence Athletic Center | Class C Champion | |||
| 3 Trinity (9-10) | ||||
| 89-70 | 3 Trinity (10-10) | |||
| @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 6 Staten Island Academy (10-14) | ||||
| 73-61 | 3 Trinity (11-10) | |||
| @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 7 Columbia Prep (13-10) | ||||
| 64-60 | 2 Avenues (15-9) | |||
| @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 2 Avenues (14-9) | ||||