| 2023 PSAL Class AA Playoff Bracket | |||||
| OUTBRACKET | ROUND 1 | QUARTERFINAL | SEMI FINAL | FINAL | |
| February 27, 2023 | March 1, 2023 | March 4, 2023 | March 12, 2023 | March 17, 2023 | |
| @ Highest Seed | |||||
| 1 Eagle Academy (26-4) | |||||
| 99-65 | 1 Eagle Academy (27-4) | ||||
| 17 Francis Lewis (11-13) | @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 72-69 | 16 Thur Marshall (14-9) | ||||
| 16 Thurgood Marshall (13-9) | |||||
| 59-51 | 1 Eagle Academy (28-4) | ||||
| @ Achievement First | |||||
| 9 Wings Academy (14-9) | |||||
| 74-62 | 9 Wings Academy (15-9) | ||||
| 25 August Martin (7-13) | |||||
| 47-44 | 8 B'klyn Collegiate (18-10) | ||||
| 24 John Bowne (6-18) | @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 63-62 | 8 Bklyn Collegiate (17-10) | ||||
| 8 Bklyn Collegiate (16-10) | |||||
| 69-53 | 4 Jefferson (21-10) | ||||
| @ Queens College | |||||
| 5 Susan Wagner (21-4) | |||||
| 94-50 | 5 Susan Wagner (22-4) | ||||
| 28 Gompers (5-15) | |||||
| 83-73 | 5 Susan Wagner (23-4) | ||||
| 21 Erasmus (7-15) | @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 87-62 | 12 HS for Const (17-6) | ||||
| 12 HS for Const (16-6) | |||||
| 88-78 | 4 Jefferson (20-10) | ||||
| @ Uncommon Charter | |||||
| 13 Stevenson (14-12) | |||||
| 71-66 | 13 Stevenson (15-12) | ||||
| 20 Eagle Academy III (12-10) | |||||
| 79-58 | 4 Jefferson (19-10) | ||||
| 29 Mott Haven (4-12) | @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 123-49 | 4 Jefferson (18-10) | ||||
| 4 Jefferson (17-10) | |||||
| 66-65 | 3 Eagle Acad II (23-6) | ||||
| 3 Eagle Academy II (18-6) | @ Barclay Center | Class AA Champion | |||
| 105-17 | 3 Eagle Academy II (19-6) | ||||
| 30 Manhattan Center (1-16) | |||||
| 86-41 | 3 Eagle Academy II (20-6) | ||||
| 19 W.H.E.E.L.S. (12-11) | @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 62-50 | 14 Camp Magnet (18-10) | ||||
| 14 Campus Magnet (17-10) | |||||
| 72-46 | 3 Eagle Academy II (21-6) | ||||
| @ Achievement First | |||||
| 11 Forest Hills (15-8) | |||||
| 74-50 | 11 Forest Hills (16-8) | ||||
| 22 JFK Campus (9-13) | |||||
| 56-45 | 11 Forest Hills (17-8) | ||||
| 27 HS for Teaching (11-12) | @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 68-52 | 6 Monroe (17-12) | ||||
| 6 Monroe (16-12) | |||||
| 60-57 | 3 Eagle Acad II (22-6) | ||||
| 7 Cardozo (25-3) | @ Queens College | ||||
| 78-68 | 7 Cardozo (26-3) | ||||
| 26 Lincoln (4-21) | |||||
| 92-48 | 7 Cardozo (27-3) | ||||
| 23 Truman (3-15) | @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 79-43 | 10 Boys & Girls (14-9) | ||||
| 10 Boys & Girls (13-9) | |||||
| 74-64 | 2 South Shore (20-8) | ||||
| @ Uncommon Charter | |||||
| 15 Curtis (19-7) | |||||
| 49-44 | 15 Curtis (20-7) | ||||
| 18 Canarsie (10-14) | |||||
| 72-58 | 2 South Shore (19-8) | ||||
| 31 Springfield (0-14) | @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 89-29 | 2 South Shore (18-8) | ||||
| 2 South Shore (17-8) | |||||