| 2024 CHSAA AA NY Archdiocesan Playoff Bracket | ||||
| QUARTERFINAL | SEMI FINAL | FINAL | ||
| February 18, 2024 | February 20, 2024 | February 24, 2024 | ||
| 1 Archbishop Stepinac (20-3) | ||||
| 85-63 | 1 Archbishop Stepinac (21-3) | |||
| @ Mount St. Michael | ||||
| 5 St. Peter's (18-6) | ||||
| 74-66 | 4 Monsignor Scanlan (16-9) | |||
| St. Raymond | ||||
| 4 Monsignor Scanlan (15-9) | ||||
| 57-51 | 2 St. Raymond (22-5) | |||
| @ Mount St. Michael | Archdiocesan Champion | |||
| 3 Iona Prep (17-7) | ||||
| 76-72 | 6 Cardinal Hayes (13-12) | |||
| St. Raymond | ||||
| 6 Cardinal Hayes (12-12) | ||||
| 63-58 | 2 St. Raymond (21-5) | |||
| @ Mount St. Michael | ||||
| 7 Mount St. Michael (7-16) | ||||
| 67-56 | 2 St. Raymond (20-5) | |||
| St. Raymond | ||||
| 2 St. Raymond (19-5) | ||||