| 2024 New York City Athletic League Tournament | |||
| NYSAIS | |||
| QUARTERFINAL | SEMI FINAL | FINAL | |
| February 9, 2024 | February 14, 2024 | February 15, 2024 | |
| 1 Columbia Prep (19-3) | |||
| 98-77 | 1 Columbia Prep (20-3) | ||
| @ Highest Seed | |||
| 5 Grace Church (9-13) | |||
| 50-48 | 4 Calhoun (11-8) | ||
| @ Highest Seed | |||
| 4 Calhoun (10-8) | |||
| 75-74 | 1 Columbia Prep (21-3) | ||
| @ Spence Athletic Center | NYCAL CHAMPION | ||
| 3 Loyola (9-11) | |||
| 63-58 | 3 Loyola (10-11) | ||
| @ Highest Seed | |||
| 6 Browning (8-14) | |||
| 63-56 | 2 Trevor Day (11-12) | ||
| @ Highest Seed | |||
| 2 Trevor Day (10-12) | |||