| 2024 Staten Island Playoff Bracket | ||||
| PSAL/CHSAA/NYSAIS | ||||
| PLAY-IN | QUARTERFINAL | SEMI FINAL | FINAL | |
| February 8, 2024 | February 10, 2024 | February 14, 2024 | February 15, 2024 | |
| 1 ST. PETER'S (15-6) | ||||
| 79-59 | 1 ST. PETER'S (16-6) | |||
| @ Petrides | ||||
| 9 MOORE CATHOLIC (11-8) | ||||
| CHSAA | ||||
| 87-82 | 9 MOORE CATHOLIC (12-8) | |||
| @ Moore Catholic | ||||
| 8 CURTIS (1-24) | ||||
| PSAL | ||||
| 53-31 | 1 ST. PETER'S (17-6) | |||
| @ Petrides | ||||
| 5 PORT RICHMOND (12-10) | ||||
| PSAL | ||||
| 48-45 | 12 CSI MCCOWN (14-11) | |||
| @ Port Richmond | ||||
| 12 CSI MCCOWN (13-11) | ||||
| PSAL | ||||
| 59-36 | 4 ST JOSEPH BTS (11-11) | |||
| @ Petrides | ||||
| 13 EAGLE ACADEMY IV (5-13) | ||||
| PSAL | ||||
| 73-47 | 4 ST JOSEPH BTS (10-11) | |||
| @ Moore Catholic | ||||
| 4 ST JOSEPH BTS (9-11) | ||||
| CHSAA | ||||
| 51-40 | 1 ST. PETER'S (18-6) | |||
| @ CSI McCown | Staten Island Champion | |||
| 3 TOTTENVILLE (14-6) | ||||
| PSAL | ||||
| 74-40 | 3 TOTTENVILLE (15-6) | |||
| @ Farrell | ||||
| 14 SI ACADEMY | ||||
| NYSAIS | ||||
| 48-47 | 3 TOTTENVILLE (16-6) | |||
| @ Petrides | ||||
| 11 NEW DORP (11-8) | ||||
| PSAL | ||||
| 66-58 | 11 NEW DORP (12-8) | |||
| @ Moore Catholic | ||||
| 6 MCKEE SI/TECH (13-11) | ||||
| PSAL | ||||
| 62-60 (OT) | 3 TOTTENVILLE (17-6) | |||
| @ Petrides | ||||
| 7 MONSIGNOR FARRELL (10-11) | ||||
| CHSAA | ||||
| 50-38 | 7 MONSIGNOR FARRELL (11-11) | |||
| @ Farrell | ||||
| 10 PETRIDES (17-5) | ||||
| PSAL | ||||
| 47-43 (OT) | 2 SUSAN WAGNER (14-9) | |||
| @ Petrides | ||||
| 2 SUSAN WAGNER (13-9) | ||||