| 2024 NYSAIS Class C Playoff Bracket | ||||
| ROUND 1 | QUARTERFINAL | SEMI FINAL | FINAL | |
| February 21, 2024 | February 23, 2024 | February 25, 2024 | February 27, 2024 | |
| 1 Fieldston (15-9) | ||||
| 72-63 | 1 Fieldston (16-9) | |||
| 9 Churchill (12-7) | @ Highest Seed | |||
| 78-52 | 8 Portledge (11-13) | |||
| @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 8 Portledge (10-13) | ||||
| 56-36 | 1 Fieldston (17-9) | |||
| @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 5 Trinity (7-11) | ||||
| 48-45 | 4 Rye Country Day (8-14) | |||
| @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 4 Rye Country Day (7-14) | ||||
| 54-32 | 1 Fieldston (18-9) | |||
| @ Fieldston | Class C Champion | |||
| 3 Columbia Prep (21-3) | ||||
| 87-86 | 6 Collegiate (14-12) | |||
| @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 6 Collegiate (13-12) | ||||
| 47-46 | 6 Collegiate (15-12) | |||
| @ Grace Church | ||||
| 7 Packer (13-9) | ||||
| 55-49 | 2 Friends Seminary (20-7) | |||
| @ Grace Church | ||||
| 2 Friends Seminary (19-7) | ||||