| 2024 PSAL Class AA Playoff Bracket | |||||
| OUTBRACKET | ROUND 1 | QUARTERFINAL | SEMI FINAL | FINAL | |
| February 27&28 | March 4, 2024 | March 6, 2024 | March 10, 2024 | March 17, 2024 | |
| @ Highest Seed | |||||
| 1 Banneker (23-2) | |||||
| 58-45 | 1 Banneker (24-2) | ||||
| 17 Amer. Studies (13-8) | @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 54-46 | 17 Amer. Studies (14-8) | ||||
| 16 Pace (10-9) | |||||
| 44-33 | 1 Banneker (25-2) | ||||
| @ Highest Seed | |||||
| 9 Adams St. (15-5) | |||||
| 62-43 | 9 Adams St. (16-5) | ||||
| 24 Morrisania (8-6) | |||||
| 44-42 | 8 Beacon (16-6) | ||||
| 25 Uncommon Charter (12-9) | @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 55-52 | 8 Beacon (15-6) | ||||
| 8 Beacon (14-6) | |||||
| 64-59 | 5 Seward Park (26-6) | ||||
| @ Queensborough CC | |||||
| 5 Seward Park (22-6) | |||||
| 66-44 | 5 Seward Park (23-6) | ||||
| 28 E Harlem Pride (8-11) | |||||
| 53-50 | 5 Seward Park (24-6) | ||||
| 21 Lab Museum (13-6) | @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 59-48 | 12 Wingate (11-11) | ||||
| 12 Wingate (10-11) | |||||
| 67-58 | 5 Seward Park (25-6) | ||||
| @ Highest Seed | |||||
| 13 Goldstein (12-7) | |||||
| 68-51 | 13 Goldstein (13-7) | ||||
| 20 KIPP (11-8) | |||||
| 50-47 | 13 Goldstein (14-7) | ||||
| @ Highest Seed | |||||
| 4 Fannie Lou Hamer (21-4) | |||||
| 58-53 | 3 S Bronx Prep (23-8) | ||||
| @ LIU | Class AA Champion | ||||
| 3 S Bronx Prep (18-8) | |||||
| 94-46 | 3 S Bronx Prep (19-8) | ||||
| 19 Hunter (9-18) | @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 58-42 | 14 Townsend Harris (16-9) | ||||
| 14 Townsend Harris (15-9) | |||||
| 91-78 | 3 S Bronx Prep (20-8) | ||||
| @ Highest Seed | |||||
| 11 Medgar Evers (15-5) | |||||
| 59-46 | 22 Democracy Prep (9-9) | ||||
| 22 Democracy Prep (8-9) | |||||
| 61-57 | 22 Democracy Prep (10-9) | ||||
| 28 Environ/Studies (9-6) | @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 64-55 | 6 Maspeth (19-5) | ||||
| 6 Maspeth (18-5) | |||||
| 66-63 | 3 S Bronx Prep (21-8) | ||||
| 7 Scholars Acad (15-4) | @ Queensborough CC | ||||
| 69-59 | 7 Scholars Acad (16-4) | ||||
| 26 South Bronx (15-7) | |||||
| 66-65 | 7 Scholars Acad (17-4) | ||||
| 23 Fred Douglass (8-13) | @ Highest Seed | ||||
| 54-46 | 10 Macchiarola (14-6) | ||||
| 10 Macchiarola (13-6) | |||||
| 55-43 | 2 AP Randolph (19-3) | ||||
| @ Highest Seed | |||||
| 15 Boerum Hill (11-8) | |||||
| 48-47 | 18 Bathgate (11-7) | ||||
| 18 Bathgate (10-7) | |||||
| 72-31 | 2 AP Randolph (18-3) | ||||
| @ Highest Seed | |||||
| 2 AP Randolph (17-3) | |||||